Why the VideoLarygoscopy don’t gonna kill the DirectLaryngoscopy (at least in the near future)

17 Ago

A novel publication goes to enrich the long-living debate on direct laryngoscopy (DL) vs video laryngoscopy (VL) efficacy in emergency intubation.

The recent article, pubblished on JEMS and titled  “Deploying the Video Laryngoscope into a Ground EMS System” ,compares the success rate beetwen DL vs VL in a ground EMS Service. The device used was the King Vision with channeled blade. The partecipants had a prior training on the divide, consisting in didactic orientation and practical skills on manikins.

The result of the study shown that “Within the first 100 days of the study, the video laryngoscope utilizing the channeled blade has shown to be at least as effective as DL in relation to first-attempt success” and considering that “the mean experience in our group with DL is nine years, yet the success rate remains unacceptable” “It’s time to consider transition from a skill that’s difficult to obtain and maintain to one that appears to have a quicker learning curve and will likely result in decreased episodes of multiple attempts at intubation and associated complications.”

So is direct laryngoscopy dead?( Or will be so in a few years)

Laryndo dead

Here are some considerations

There are some fundamental differences in  VL tecnique respect the DL tecnique, that makes the DL more intuitive to pass the tube trough the cords.

We have basically 3 main axis in the airways


When we manage the airways we first put the head in “sniffing position” aligning the pharyngeal axis with the laryngeal one

Sniffing position

Then we use the laryngoscope to align the mouth axis having so a direct view of the cords. This view coincide with the way to pass the tube, making this step intitive and easy.

DL view














When using the videolaryngoscope we take our eyes right in front of the larynx, having a perfect “video” view of the vocal cords, but also minimally modifying the axis of the mouth.

Visione in videolaringoscopia

For this reason passing the OTT is not straight forward, so we need the stylet, the Bougie/Froban or the external glottic maneuvers, to facilitate the intubation.

tubo stylet


This difference in tecnique makes the VL not so intuitive  due to the contrast between the perfect laryngeal view and the not  intuitive passage of the tube trough the cords.

In fact the available evidences almost accordingly demonstrate an equivalent success first pass rate beetwen traditional laryngoscope an video but a prolonged intubation time in VL groups.

As the previously cited article demonstrate the learning curve for VL is short and easy to perform, and this make this tecnique surely suitable for emergency intubation.

But for emergency professionals well trained and familiar with DL I think this has to be the first choice approach when managing an emergent airway.

Emergency field is not the place to make trianing or experience with novel devices or drugs.

The still not widely availability of video-laryngoscope makes this device a perfect alternative in all the casess when is not possible to obtain a good laryngela view with DL, but still not the gold standard tecnique.

In the future the increasingly diffusion of videoleryngoscopes (due mostly to more affordable prices), will chenge the airway management scenario. Novel emergency medicine operators will grown up parallel experience wid DL and VL so the latter will be more suitable as first choice device.

Bottom line

Wich way you prefer to go home?

The quickest and the shorter one for sure!

Do you use the GPS to go home?

Agree, me neither!

And when you use it?


Right! When you are lost!

So that’s why Direct Laryngoscope il still my Plan A

My straight way home!

straight road

Prehospital Airway Management Action Plan



2 Risposte a “Why the VideoLarygoscopy don’t gonna kill the DirectLaryngoscopy (at least in the near future)”

  1. KIdocs.org 17 agosto 2014 a 12:32 PM #

    Very nice summary!

  2. Orla 17 agosto 2014 a 10:19 PM #

    Ottimo post! Condivido a pieno ciò che hai scritto !

    I’m totally agree with you about the technique to choose in prehospital setting



Inserisci i tuoi dati qui sotto o clicca su un'icona per effettuare l'accesso:

Logo di WordPress.com

Stai commentando usando il tuo account WordPress.com. Chiudi sessione /  Modifica )

Foto di Facebook

Stai commentando usando il tuo account Facebook. Chiudi sessione /  Modifica )

Connessione a %s...

Questo sito utilizza Akismet per ridurre lo spam. Scopri come vengono elaborati i dati derivati dai commenti.


A Site for Intensivists and Resuscitationists


Supporting ALL Ohio EM Residencies in the #FOAMed World


Let's try to make it simple

thinking critical care

a blog for thinking docs: blending good evidence, physiology, common sense, and applying it at the bedside!


More definitive diagnosis, better patient care

Critical Care Northampton

Reviewing Critical Care, Journals and FOAMed

OHCA research

Prehospital critical care for out-of-hospital cardiac arrest


Education and entertainment for the ultrasound enthusiast




Emergency medicine - When minutes matter...

Songs or Stories

Sharing the Science and Art of Paediatric Anaesthesia


"Live as if you will die tomorrow; Learn as if you will live forever"


Navigating resuscitation

Life in the Fast Lane • LITFL

Emergency medicine and critical care education blog

emDOCs.net - Emergency Medicine Education

Our goal is to inform the global EM community with timely and high yield content about what providers like YOU are seeing and doing everyday in your local ED.

The Collective

A Hive Mind for Prehospital and Retrieval Med

Dave on Airways

Thoughts and opinions on airways and resuscitation science


A Free Open Access Medical Education Emergency Medicine Core Content Mash Up

Broome Docs

Rural Generalist Doctors Education


Emergency Medicine #FOAMed

"CardioOnline"Basic and Advanced Cardiovascular medicine" Cariology" concepts and Review -Dr.Nabil Paktin,MD.FACC.دکتـور نبــــیل "پاکطــــین

این سایت را به آن دکتوران و محصلین طب که شب و روز برای رفاه نوع انسان فداکاری می کنند ، جوانی و لذایذ زندگی را بدون چشمداشت به امتیاز و نفرین و آفرین قربان خدمت به بشر می کنند و بار سنگین خدمت و اصلاح را بدوش می کشند ، اهداء می کنم This site is dedicated to all Doctors and students that aver the great responsibility of People’s well-being upon their shoulders and carry on their onerous task with utmost dedication and Devotionاولین سایت و ژورنال انتــرنتی علـــمی ،تخـصصی ، پــژوهشــی و آمــوزشــی طبـــی در افغــانســـتان


Free Open Access Medical Education

Little Medic

Learning everything I can from everywhere I can. This is my little blog to keep track of new things medical, paramedical and pre-hospital from a student's perspective.

Prehospital Emergency Medicine Blog

All you want to know about prehospital emergency medicine

Italy Customized Tour Operator in Florence

Check out our updated blog posts at https://www.italycustomized.it/blog


The FOAM Search Engine

EM Lyceum

where everything is up for debate . . .

Pediatric EM Morsels

Pediatric Emergency Medicine Education


Free Open Access Medical Education for Paramedics

Rural Doctors Net

useful resources for rural clinicians

Auckland HEMS

Unofficial site for prehospital care providers of the Auckland HEMS service




Prehospital Emergency Medicine

EM Basic

Your Boot Camp Guide to Emergency Medicine

KI Doc


Emergency Live

Prehospital Emergency Medicine


Academic Medicine Pearls in Emergency Medicine from THE Ohio State University Residency Program

Prehospital Emergency Medicine

 Academic Life in Emergency Medicine

Prehospital Emergency Medicine

Comments on: Homepage

Prehospital Emergency Medicine

Greater Sydney Area HEMS

The Pre-hospital & Retrieval Medicine Team of NSW Ambulance

%d blogger hanno fatto clic su Mi Piace per questo: